During the moment when Jamal Roberts was announced as the winner of Season 23, fans noticed something odd: while the other judges stood and applauded, Underwood remained seated. Viewers called her reaction “cold,” “unenthusiastic,” and “disconnected.” The criticism spread quickly online, with many accusing her of lacking support for the show’s outcome.
She added fuel to the fire when she remarked that Roberts “needed to be more animated” — despite receiving high praise from her fellow judges. That comment didn’t sit well with Idol fans who felt it was unnecessarily harsh and dismissive.
Retreat or Reset? Carrie Steps Away From the Spotlight
Following the finale, Underwood retreated to her secluded Nashville estate, prompting speculation that she may be distancing herself from the show — and from the criticism.
When asked directly about her future on Idol, Carrie responded vaguely:
“I don’t know. There’s a lot to consider.”
That lack of clarity, combined with the recent backlash, has left many wondering whether her time on the judging panel is coming to an end.
Behind the Scenes: Was Carrie the Network’s First Choice?
Insiders claim that Carrie Underwood was not ABC’s top pick to replace Katy Perry this season. While her contract was financially favorable for the network, internal concerns have reportedly grown about her on-camera energy, public perception, and the chemistry she brings to the judging panel.
With producers aiming to preserve the show’s brand reputation and fan loyalty, there’s now strong reason to believe the panel could be refreshed again before the next season airs.
Who Could Replace Carrie? These Two Stars Top the List
If a change is coming, two iconic names have quickly emerged as fan favorites for the potential seat at the judges’ table.
1. Katy Perry – The Fan-Favorite Return
After stepping away at the end of Season 22, Katy Perry is still widely considered the heart of Idol’s recent success. With her bold style, unfiltered honesty, and a proven connection with viewers and contestants alike, many are begging for her return.
Why she’s perfect to return:
-
Strong emotional connection with contestants
-
Great chemistry with Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie
-
Massive online following and built-in Idol loyalty
-
Known for balancing fun with firm, thoughtful feedback
Perry’s comeback would feel like a homecoming, restoring the vibrant spark many fans felt was missing this season.
2. Kelly Clarkson – The Ultimate Idol Comeback
Who better to sit on the Idol judging panel than its very first champion?
Kelly Clarkson, now a household name and daytime TV powerhouse, brings the perfect mix of experience, heart, and perspective. She’s mentored artists on The Voice and has proven herself as a trusted voice in both music and television.
✅ Why Kelly is a top choice:
-
Deep Idol legacy and credibility
-
TV hosting experience with The Kelly Clarkson Show and The Voice
-
Known for warmth, relatability, and fierce support of new talent
-
Would instantly energize the fan base and attract new viewers
Her presence on the panel would represent a full-circle Idol moment — inspiring contestants while reigniting excitement for long-time fans.
🔮 What’s Next for Idol?
As of now, ABC has not made an official announcement about any judge replacements. But with viewer pressure mounting, internal concerns reportedly growing, and Carrie’s own response uncertain, change seems increasingly likely.
Whether it’s Katy Perry’s return or a Kelly Clarkson comeback, one thing is certain: American Idol’s future will depend on finding a judge who brings energy, empathy, and star power — and connects with the audience from the first note to the final vote.