While some viewers slammed it as ‘absolutely disgusting’, others celebrated it as ‘a classic’. The film sparked a wave of online chatter, drawing intense opinions from both ends of the spectrum. Some applauded its emotional weight and storytelling, while others were taken aback by its graphic imagery.
Many people, who went in expecting a slow-paced indie film based on its festival success and awards, were completely caught off guard by just how explicit it really was.
Another declared: “No, no. Double no. Absolutely not.”
A third viewer didn’t hold back, warning: “This is way too much for Netflix,” while another added: “Wtf is this doing on Netflix. I can’t imagine what it would do to the sensibilities of unsuspecting families opening it for a mindless Sunday viewing.”
Most of the criticism comes from how boldly the film handles subjects like teenage sexuality, longing, drug use, and full-frontal nudity. These themes stirred controversy back when it first came out and are still stirring strong reactions today.
It originally received an NC-17 rating in the United States and was given an 18+ rating in Mexico—a decision the filmmakers famously pushed back on in court. So, this isn’t the first time the movie has sparked debate.
“A classic. If you haven’t seen it, drop everything and watch,” one excited fan posted.
“I’ve seen it many times, and notice something new with each viewing.”
Others praised it in even more straightforward ways: “I really liked this one! They show everything!!!”
Despite the split reactions, Y Tu Mamá También still earns praise from critics for its depth, layered narrative, and subtle political undertones.
It’s not just known for controversy. The movie has earned high praise, being listed in Empire’s 100 Best Films of World Cinema and even receiving Oscar and Golden Globe nominations. Still, that hasn’t stopped it from stirring strong reactions.
You can check out the trailer for Y Tu Mamá También here…